Warm Water Cove Update: A Fascinating Document Explains Why the Graffiti is Still Gone

You know about Yelp-rated Warm Water Cove aka Toxic Tire Beach, that mini park where 24th Street almost meets the bay? Well, take a look at the changes.

Here it is as it was, at least the north side anyway, from back in aught-seven: 

And here is how that Historic Sugar House looks today:

“Concrete Beach” via CaliberSF‘s Troy Holden (Whoops, this caption didn’t take earlier today, my bad.)

That’s quite a change, huh? Looks like DHL Worldwide Express done moved in. (Which is apropos, since DHL got it’s start in San Francisco. Speaking of which, the “H” in DHL created DHL while he was going to UC Berkeley’s Boalt Hall. (I’m probably still on their waiting list, oh well.) Read his fascinating life story about how he killed himself with a seaplane and also read about some suspicious acts by the people employed the aforementioned University of California here.)   

Anywho, the graffiti eradication program is all documented right here in “Warm Water Cove Graffiti Vandalism Project 2007″ at SFGov.org. This pdf has it all, it even shows how the SFPD catches anyone who would dare throw some urban art on the empty walls.

The mellow artists were no match for the determined City and County:

I’ll tell you back in aught-seven, it was widely predicted that the graffiti people would come back with a vengeance. I know that there have been subsequent incidents, but the City is still putting enough energy into this project to keep the place graffiti-free.

Score this a minor victory for Mayor Gavin Newsom.

More deets after the jump.

Warm Water Cove

Established: 1976
Location: end of 24th Street, east of Illinois Street
Transportation: Third Street Light Rail, 23rd and 3rd Street stop
Contact: Corinne Woods, 415.902.7635

Photo of Warm Water Cove by Mike Ernst

Deteriorated but deserving, Warm Water Cove is awaiting its makeover. The indispensable first step is passage of the 2008 Park Bond, in February. Nestled on the Central Waterfront between China Basin and Candlestick Point, Warm Water Cove sits at the end of 24th Street, east of Illinois Street and close to the new Third Street light rail. It’s one of the parks embedded in the Blue Greenway, San Francisco’s vision for the southern part of the regional Bay Trail and the Bay Water Trail.

Owned by the Port of San Francisco and the Mirant Corporation (owners of the adjacent power plant), the two-acre park was established in 1976, according to David Beaupre, senior waterfront planner. From its beginning, the park and Cove, withits spectacular views of the Bay, have coexisted with and been damaged by homeless encampments, drug users and graffiti artists. The Homeless Church bus that held Sunday services for the squatters has now gone, but needles and trash remain. The wooden picnic tables, benches and the fishing pier have been burned several times, and graffiti ‘artists’ continue to tag, undiscouraged after their work is painted over. The long-standing cache of sunken tires in the Cove’s water is still on view at low tide.

In 2002, the SF Planning Department’s Central Waterfront Neighborhood Plan noted that the park “. . . should be improved in order to attract the activity necessary to making Warm Water Cove a pleasing and safe destination.” Most park users, from the adjacent Dogpatch and Potrero Hill neighborhoods, agreed. In 2004 the Port installed an accessible and unburnable concrete picnic table, paved pathways, and new signage. But today blogs and media stories about the Cove reflect contentious and ongoing problems.

Periodic cleanups have had little lasting effect. Early this summer the Port, DPW and the community dredged up a mass of old tires, cleaned the grounds of brush and refuse, and repaved the paths. In August, a heavy duty cleanup team included the Port’s Tom Carter, deputy director of maintenance; Mohammed Nuru, deputy director for operations, SF Department of Public Works; Merle Goldstone, public information officer for DPW community programs; Corinne Woods, Blue Greenway coordinator of Neighborhood Parks Council; and Project Connect. They marshaled 100 volunteers who picked up trash, trimmed trees and painted over the graffiti-covered walls. This effort may have a longer life because, says Carter, the Port’s maintenance department, the SF Police Department and DPW are now monitoring the park on a daily basis. Susan Lavin, homeless coordinator in the BayviewPolice Department, reports that over the last two years, the homeless count has gone from 30 or 40 to 1. Two families with young children have been moved into new three-bedroom apartments. One child, four years old, said she had never slept in a bed before.

In October 2007, NPC’s monthly coalition meeting featured a presentation by Mike Ernst, a graduate student in city planning and recipient of the first SPUR Piero Patri Fellowship in Urban Design. Mike set out his visionary land-use plan to expand and revitalize the Cove, integrating the adjoining neighborhoods–innovative concepts for the days of planning that are just ahead.

“We’re preparing now for the long term future of Warm Water Cove,” Corinne Woods, NPC’s Blue GreenWayCoordinator explains. “In creating a master plan we will be meeting with managers of the Port, PUC, DPW, artists, dog owners, skate boarders, and other members of the community. The plan might include art, music and recreational elements.” Robin Talmadge of PotreroHill is working with Supervisor Sophie Maxwell on a pilot off-leash dog park.

“The Port has invested significant funds and labor over the years to encourage responsible park users. But without park stewards, the unlawful camping, dumping and graffiti will continue,” says David Beaupre of the Port. “The goal,” Woods agrees, “is to create stewardship. The 120 NPC ‘Friends’ groups work to maintain and improve their parks. It’s the only way to protect their environment.” Clearly this orphan park needs to see a “Friends of Warm Water Cove” in its future.

–Jeanne Alexander
Winter 2007
Published in Parks Report #43

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

One Response to “Warm Water Cove Update: A Fascinating Document Explains Why the Graffiti is Still Gone”

  1. […] Warm Water Cove Update: A Fascinating Document Explains Why the … […]